I wrote up a short piece about the impact of social media in the 2012 election. It will come out in print this month and I wanted to share it here as well.
Tag Archives: Election 2012
Will the ‘Real Romney’ please stand up?!
Tonight, Maxwell School’s Campbell Institute hosted journalist Michael Kranish, The Boston Globe, and author of “Real Romney” as part of the State of Democracy lecture series.
The expectation of many audience members was to get a behind-the-scene view of presidential candidate Romney by an insider who has researched and covered him for over 18 years for The Boston Globe.
Kranish is a great story teller, a diligent researcher: For this book, he and his coauthor followed Romney’s career during the last 18 years, interviewed his business partners to understand how the candidate’s environment, upbringing, religious context, business experience at Bain Capital have shaped his political decision making.
After his introductory lecture, Kranish was asked several times – in different ways – who the real Mitt Romney is, how his status in the The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints as the local “bishop” will shape his decision making as a potential president. Kranish did not provide a response directly to the question, instead quoted Romney with: “I want to be a Mormon who runs for presidency, and not a mormon president.” Earlier although he did hint at the fact that Romney had said several times, that his faith has shaped who he is today and that it is a large part of himself as a person.
Besides the Mormon faith, Romney’s sense of the middle-class, or “the poor” were questioned, but not transcribed in the attached list of tweets: Kranish talked a lot about Romney’s success at Bain Capital, an investment firm created as a spin-off from Bain Consulting, that was created to invest rich investors’ money into companies and sell the companies at a profit. Kranish reports, that Romney personally must have made ~ $25-30 million in profits when he sold Staples after consolidating the company. The Boston Globe reviewed ~100 transactions during Romney’s tenure at Bain Capital and – you make the math – traced Romney’s share of the profits. Again, not a straight answer to the question wether Romney is able to understand those part of the society who are not able to make millions of dollars per year. Kranish pointed to the experiences that shape a politicians life which will provide the context in which he might most likely make decisions in the future.
Overall, many questions were unanswered, especially because Kranish’ did not draw any conclusions from his research and did not want to provide theories through his personal lens.
Here is a list of tweets transcribing and commenting on the author’s lecture in chronological order:
Kranish is an SU alum, and deputy chief of the Washington Bureau of The Boston Globe. #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
Prof. McClure dismissed the usefulness of social media for public good & improved public information. I disagree #SoDKranish #ElectionClass—
Billy Kluttz (@bekluttz) September 14, 2012
"We need a full scale understanding of who the candidate is. How did this person become who they are?" #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
Kranish: people tend to view information through their own tunnel. Need a full scale understanding of presidential candidates. #SODkranish—
John Fornof (@Jfornof) September 14, 2012
"There's a concern that people just turn into the news channel that reaffirms their opinions" Michael Kranish #SoDKranish—
Alexandra Solimanto (@ASolimanto) September 14, 2012
#SoDKranish #ElectionClass Boston Globe has been covering @MittRomney for 18 years!—
Emily Ruddock (@emilyruddock) September 14, 2012
Kranish: you can't understand Romney w/o understanding his development over time #SoDKranish #ElectionClass—
Billy Kluttz (@bekluttz) September 14, 2012
George Romney walked out on 1964 RNC for extremist conservatism #SODKranish #circleoflife—
Amanda Claypool (@amanda_lynna) September 14, 2012
Mitt Romney grew up "in a series of bubbles." #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
Kranish: Mitt watched his father lose his pres. bid by speaking frankly, fighting against extreme partisanship within his party #SODkranish—
John Fornof (@Jfornof) September 14, 2012
Romney's wife Ann told him to run for Senate. "If you don't do it you will always regret it." #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
"Mitt Romney's greatest political accomplishment was working with a 85% Democratic legislature as governor." #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
Romney learned lessons from '08 primary campaign, but still has trouble connecting with average voters. #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
"How will you connect with the people?" a question that ought to be continuously asked to all candidates #SODKranish #electionclass—
Rama H. (@RamaWJH) September 14, 2012
Kranish: Romney overcame Mormon issue by discussing religious service, not beliefs | Great alternative framing. #SoDKranish #electionclass—
Billy Kluttz (@bekluttz) September 14, 2012
"Does Mitt Romney understand the average person? To have difficulties with money? You see a turn in the convention." #SoDKranish I agree.—
Cruz (@Sierra_Cuse) September 14, 2012
#SoDKranish Romney is a market based person and applies to him in politics- a driven pragmatism #ElectionClass—
Emily Ruddock (@emilyruddock) September 14, 2012
“@SUSqueeze:I've covered a lot of politicians over the years, they've all changed their positions at some point." #SODKranish #ElectionClass—
Emily Ruddock (@emilyruddock) September 14, 2012
#SoDKranish Romney set up tax return paradigm himself in '94 Senate run. #ElectionClass—
Emily Ruddock (@emilyruddock) September 14, 2012
Boston Globe and others have been asking Romney to release tax info. since 1994, when he originally promised to release them. #SODkranish—
John Fornof (@Jfornof) September 14, 2012
Romney is a spreadsheet geek, analytical person who asks, "What does the data mean?" #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
"[His partners] sometimes grimaced when Romney came in with his own idea" #SoDKranish #ElectionClass—
Billy Kluttz (@bekluttz) September 14, 2012
Kranish: Benghazi press conference was pivotal moment for Romney campaign #SoDKranish #ElectionClass | Important social media moment as well—
Billy Kluttz (@bekluttz) September 14, 2012
Live webcast from MAXaud! #SoDKranish instagr.am/p/PketewuUhu/—
ICT @MaxwellSU (@ICTMaxwell) September 14, 2012
Romney not a true neoconservative, says Kranish. Has a wide variety of foreign policy advisers with different philosophies. #SODKranish—
SyracuseU Live (@SUSqueeze) September 14, 2012
"No Apology" policy of the Romney campaign seen as an effective campaign tactic #SoDKranish #ElectionClass—
Ines Mergel (@InesMergel) September 14, 2012
#SoDKranish "When you are running a campaign you want to see what sticks" #ElectionClass how to manage this in a ever changing news cycle?—
Emily Ruddock (@emilyruddock) September 14, 2012
"There are some things that we're are not going to know about Mitt Romney unless he becomes President" Michael Kranish #SoDKranish—
Alexandra Solimanto (@ASolimanto) September 14, 2012
#SoDKranish wrote a down the middle book. For such an important decision people want to know who the candidate is. #ElectionClass—
Emily Ruddock (@emilyruddock) September 14, 2012
Can an unbiased reporter spending 18 years researching Mitt Romney really be unbiased? #sodkranish #electionclass—
Ines Mergel (@InesMergel) September 14, 2012
@Twitter Political Index
The next 100 days count – and Twitter is counting our sentiments and online interactions to gauge the potential outcome of the presidential campaign in the U.S.: Today, Twitter launched a new site called the Twitter Political Index. According to the Twitter blog, the @gov team is analyzing the +2 million tweets every week to understand how the nation’s Twitter users feel about President Obama and his challenger Romney.
The index represents:
Twitter teams up with USAToday’s election team and Topsy to display the sentiment results in the newspaper’s Election Meter. The sentiments are measured on a 0 to 100 scale and everything above 50 is coded as positive sentiment. A sliding scale lets users go back in time and shows sentiments including their related historical events (such as important visits, or speeches):
Adam Sharp, Twitter’s head of news and social innovation (@gov), shared some of the ideas and analysis mechanisms on NYT’s Timescast on August 2. Asked how Twindex represents the American public, he responded on Twitter:
@InesMergel #Twindex avg for 2 cands since 5/1 w/in 1 point of each other. That + frequent Gallup correlation gives us confidence in balance—
Adam Sharp (@AdamS) August 03, 2012
I was interviewed for our local channel 9 News to talk about #Twindex: PollstePollsters using social media sites to gauge popularity of candidatesrs
Related articles:
- WashingtonPost.com: Introducing the Twitter Political Index!
- NationalJournal: Twitter will gauge voter sentiment in new venture.

